HealthEngine LLC: Uncovering Critical Legal Risks in Terms & Conditions | Erayaha

## When Terms Fall Short: The Hidden Costs in HealthEngine LLC’s Legal Framework

Imagine a healthcare technology platform facing a $1.5 million HIPAA fine or a class action lawsuit over ambiguous liability waivers. Our analysis of HealthEngine LLC’s Terms & Conditions reveals four critical legal and logical errors that could expose the company to significant regulatory penalties, litigation costs, and reputational harm.

1. HIPAA Authorization Ambiguity: Insufficient Scope & Revocation Rights HealthEngine’s clause allowing ongoing access to users’ Protected Health Information (PHI) lacks clear limitations on scope, duration, and user revocation rights. This exposes the company to HIPAA enforcement actions, where fines can reach $50,000 per violation, up to $1.5 million annually.

Legal Analysis

high Risk

Removed

Added

By creating an Account, you hereby authorize HealthEngine to request, access, and retrieve your protected health information (“PHI”) solely for the purposes necessary to provide the Services, in accordance with the Health Insurance PortabilityHIPAA and Accountability Act andapplicable regulations issued thereunder (collectively, “HIPAA”). HealthEngine may obtain PHI contained in your designated record set (as that termThis authorization is defined under HIPAA)limited to provide the Service. ... Your authorization of HealthEngine pursuant to this paragraph shall continue until such time as youminimum necessary PHI, is valid for one year unless otherwise required by law, and may terminatebe revoked by you at any time upon written notice, except to the Servicesextent HealthEngine has already relied on it.

Legal Explanation

The original clause lacks clear limitations on the scope, duration, and revocation of PHI access, which is required under HIPAA. The revision specifies purpose, scope, duration, and user revocation rights, reducing regulatory risk and improving enforceability.

2. Overbroad Limitation of Liability: Potentially Unenforceable The limitation of liability clause attempts to exclude nearly all forms of damages, even in cases of negligence, and caps liability at $100 or transaction fees. Such overbroad waivers are routinely struck down in court, especially in consumer healthcare contexts, risking multi-million dollar judgments.

Legal Analysis

critical Risk

Removed

Added

TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE LAWTo the extent permitted by applicable law, HEALTHENGINEHealthEngine and its affiliates shall not be liable for indirect, ITS SUBSIDIARIES AND CORPORATE AFFILIATESincidental, ANY OTHER PARTY ... EXCLUDE ALL LIABILITY AND RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY AMOUNT OR KIND OF LOSS OR DAMAGE THAT MAY RESULT TO YOU OR A THIRD PARTY ... IN CONNECTION WITH THE WEBSITE OR SERVICES IN ANY WAY ... IFor consequential damages arising from use of the Website or Services, DESPITE THE LIMITATION ABOVEexcept for damages resulting from gross negligence, THE RELEASED PARTIES ARE FOUND LIABLE FOR ANY LOSS OR DAMAGE WHICH ARISES OUT OF OR IN ANY WAY CONNECTED WITH THE WEBSITE OR SERVICESwillful misconduct, THEN THE LIABILITY FOR THE RELEASED PARTIES WILL IN NO EVENT EXCEED, IN THE AGGREGATE, THE GREATER OFor statutory violations. In no event shall HealthEngine’s aggregate liability exceed the greater of (Aa) THE FEES ASSESSED FOR YOUR TRANSACTIONS ON THIS WEBSITEthe total fees paid by you for the Services in the preceding twelve months, ORor (Bb) ONE-HUNDRED DOLLARS (US$1001,000.00) This limitation does not apply to liability that cannot be excluded under applicable law.

Legal Explanation

The original clause is overly broad and attempts to exclude liability even for negligence, which courts often find unenforceable, especially in healthcare. The revision narrows the exclusion, aligns with legal standards, and increases the liability cap to a commercially reasonable amount.

3. Unilateral Amendment Clause: Lack of Notice and Consent HealthEngine reserves the right to modify Terms “at any time” and deems continued use as acceptance, without requiring affirmative user consent or reasonable notice. This practice is increasingly challenged under consumer protection laws (e.g., FTC, Illinois Consumer Fraud Act), risking contract unenforceability and regulatory scrutiny.

Legal Analysis

high Risk

Removed

Added

HealthEngine reserves the right, at any time, tomay modify, alter, or update these Terms of Use, and you agree to be bound by such modifications, alterations, or updates if you continueproviding at least 30 days’ advance notice to users via email and prominent notice on the Website. Continued use after the siteeffective date constitutes acceptance. SuchMaterial changes require affirmative user consent, modifications, additions or deletions will be effective immediately upon notice to you, which may be givenexcept where required by any means, including but not limited to posting on this Website or by electronic or conventional maillaw.

Legal Explanation

The original clause allows unilateral changes without adequate notice or consent, which can be found unconscionable and unenforceable under consumer protection laws. The revision introduces reasonable notice and consent requirements, reducing regulatory risk.

4. Termination Without Cause or Notice: No User Remedy The right to terminate user access “at any time, in its sole discretion, with or without cause and without notice” creates a significant imbalance and may be deemed unconscionable. This exposes HealthEngine to breach of contract claims and potential statutory damages.

Legal Analysis

medium Risk

Removed

Added

HealthEngine reserves the right to denymay terminate or revokesuspend user access to this Websitefor material breach of these Terms of Use, or any part thereof, orsubject to otherwise terminate a user’s accessreasonable notice and an opportunity to its Websitecure, at any time in its sole discretion, withexcept where immediate termination is required by law or without cause and without notice to youprotect the security of the Website or users.

Legal Explanation

The original clause allows termination without cause or notice, which may be unconscionable and unenforceable. The revision introduces cause, notice, and cure period, aligning with contract law standards and reducing litigation risk.

Conclusion: Proactive Legal Protection is Essential Our examination shows that HealthEngine LLC’s Terms & Conditions contain preventable legal risks that could result in regulatory fines, costly litigation, and reputational damage. Proactive contract redlining and legal review can help avoid these pitfalls and strengthen enforceability.

How would your business survive a multi-million dollar lawsuit over a single ambiguous clause?
Are your terms and conditions defensible against evolving regulatory standards?
What’s your plan for closing legal loopholes before they become costly liabilities?

This analysis is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For actual legal guidance, consult with a licensed attorney. This assessment is based on publicly available information and professional legal analysis. See erayaha.ai’s terms of service for liability limitations.